REIT vs Buying Property Directly — Which is Better?

REIT vs Buying Property Directly — Which is Better

Introduction

For decades, investing in real estate in Pakistan meant buying land, files, or apartments — a traditional path that created fortunes but also carried risks like fake files, double sales, or legal disputes.

Now, with the rise of Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) regulated by the Securities & Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP) and secured through the Central Depository Company (CDC), investors have a new option.

The big question is: Should you invest in a REIT or buy property directly? Let’s break it down.


🔹 What is a REIT?

A Real Estate Investment Trust (REIT) is a pooled investment structure where many investors buy units (like shares) of a large real estate project.

  • Regulated by SECP
  • Digital ownership secured by CDC
  • Units can be bought or sold easily, just like stocks
  • Entry starts as low as PKR 20,000

🔹 What is Direct Property Investment?

Direct investment means you buy property in your own name — whether it’s a plot, apartment, or commercial shop.

  • You own it physically and legally
  • You manage tenants, maintenance, and resale yourself
  • Entry usually requires millions of rupees upfront
  • Returns depend on market appreciation and rental income

🔹 REIT vs Direct Property: Side-by-Side Comparison

FeatureREIT InvestmentDirect Property Investment
Starting InvestmentPKR 20,000+PKR 2–20 crore (depending on location & property type)
Ownership TypeFractional (units recorded digitally in CDC account)Full ownership (title deed, registry, allotment file)
LiquidityHigh – units can be sold like stocksLow – selling property may take months
Risk of FraudVery low – SECP & CDC regulatedHigh – risk of fake files, double sales, illegal societies
ManagementPassive – handled by REIT managersActive – you manage tenants, documents, utilities
ReturnsRental income + appreciation (distributed as dividends)Rental income + property value appreciation
DiversificationEasy – one REIT may invest in multiple projectsHard – usually tied to a single property
TransparencyHigh – regulated reports & auditsMedium – depends on society/developer reputation
Overseas AccessEasy – buy REIT units from abroad via CDCDifficult – requires trusted local representatives

🔹 Case Study: Centaurus Mall vs Taj Boulevard Tower REIT

  • Centaurus Mall: Apartments launched at PKR 2–2.5 crore, now worth PKR 18–20 crore — almost 10x growth. But ownership relied on traditional paperwork, making it risky and illiquid.
  • Taj Boulevard Tower REIT: Investors can enter with just PKR 20,000, with SECP regulation and CDC-backed digital ownership, ensuring both growth potential and security.

🔹 Who Should Choose REITs?

  • Small investors starting with limited capital
  • Overseas Pakistanis who want a secure, digital investment
  • Those seeking passive income without management headaches
  • People looking for diversified and regulated investments

🔹 Who Should Choose Direct Property?

  • High-net-worth individuals who want full control over assets
  • Investors with the patience to manage tenants, utilities, and legal work
  • People aiming for long-term inheritance or personal use
  • Those willing to lock in large capital for potential big returns

✅ Final Thoughts

Both REITs and direct property investment have their place in Pakistan’s real estate market.

  • REITs are best for small investors, overseas Pakistanis, and those seeking safety, liquidity, and transparency.
  • Direct property is better for those with larger capital who want control, inheritance value, and personal usage.

👉 If Centaurus Mall showed the power of real estate growth, Taj Boulevard Tower REIT shows how to achieve the same growth with smaller capital, higher security, and digital ownership.

No responses yet

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *